A seasonal worship trainwreck which we dig out for your listening pleasure each December – it gets better the longer you listen!
We’ve enjoyed reading your comments too.
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
I know we’ve posted this before but at over 1,000 Facebook “likes” it’s one of our most popular articles so worthy of a dig through the archives.
55 Comments
I absolutely love this track, apparently it is a real recording. I once used this in a cell group meeting, introducing it saying that, although it was a little ragged, the raw emotion was very touching. I cracked after about two minutes because everyone else was trying so hard not to laugh.
Thanks Simon. Let us know if you have any more audio or video gaffes – people love to hear them (they are one of the most popular areas of the blog) but they are fairly difficult to find.
Wow…It starts off like a lounge act and turns into…something…wow. I can’t stop listening to it.
This is a good demonstration for my praise teams, however, why I always change the key of songs to better fit a congregational range and why I will never tackle this song.
Goodness me! Straight from the “How to murder a song” archives.
I’ll have half a pint of whatever he’s had! That is, quite simply, awful. It’s given me faith in our music group…
i really like it
For the first bar I thought it might be Cliff Richards.
Totally unprepared for what happens at 2:13!
Absolutely brilliant – is there an album too??? Keep them coming!!!!
Wow – Gave me goosebumps!
I was having a bit of a low day today until I listened to this – I feel so much better now that I’ve had a good laugh. Isn’t God good. Surely this can’t be for real.
Has anyone heard of “Wing”…
I haven’t stopped laughing yet…
his he on drugs on drunk
ahah i can’t stop laughing not because he’s good he sucks !!!
Brilliant, its Tom Brennan.
Started off a bit of Carman, slid easily into some Larnelle Harris, moved suddenly to Sandi Patti, peaking at an authentic Queen anthemic overture, settled into a full-bodied “je ne s’ais pas” (or quoi!), and an after-taste of some bar dude I smelled, I mean heard, once.
The church is lucky to have him.
Love it… had me in stiches…
I think that is about how bad I butchered my solo at the church Christmas banquet last weekend, but not on purpose… just fell apart due to nerves!
Wow! Thankfully, the Lord is much more Gracious than I. That sounds like a typical try-out reject from American Idol. You gotta love the passion, but it reminds me of a bad lounge act. Bless him for trying.
great still laughing.
Reminded me of two things:
a) This is why I don’t sing in church.
b) This guy sits behind me everytime we sing a song in church.
Having been in the music ministry for longer than I care to tell right now, I can remember a few people who could have rivaled this poor misguided soul. Of course, I’m not thinking of anyone in my current choir–`:}
Trainwreck is a nice phrase. Man, you had me beating myself up! Could not make it thru…….sorry, it sounds like a trainwreck of really bad music persona impersonators: Elvis with a furball in his throat, Mick Jaggar with one too many drinks, etc…
susan Boyle eat your heart out
Okay already, so tell us where we can go buy this track. I want to pay my dollar and have this track for every christmas. :)
Pretty please. I’m serious. Can you tell us how to find this version in iTunes or something?
I did a bit of research on it earlier this year (as it’s always been a classic in our house). Here’s the story behind the recording (which was always intended to be a joke): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LiAuyM3gB5U
This is an amazing version of it, too:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRiYKf19T-k
This was done on a lark. It was done after completing a symphonic track for Guy Penrod years ago. The producer Steve Mauldin did it. Check out Youtube. He has an explanation on there.
Merry Christmas!
this is why there is duct tape.
I’m sorry, but it is the nature of this song. I’ve never heard a version which didn’t cause me pain. Some songs are simply terrible, no matter who sings them and no amount of sincerity is going to help.
OK now y’all have to go to YouTube and look up Jessica Simpson O Holy Night. She utterly tarted that up. Sounded and looked like she was gonna start humping the microphone.
Unfortunately, I’ve lived through too many of these types of sessions to find it amusing. Out-of-tune actually makes me physically nauseous, and a get a dull pain in the front of my forehead. What is appalling is that so often, almost NO ONE else even knows what is wrong. I attended a worship practice in which some were given the music in D, some in C, and no one noticed! I was staring aghast at the players and someone stopped and asked what was wrong. I am definitely not the most adept player in the least, but I do have an ear! How can you be a musician and not know you are with a group that is playing simultaneously in two different keys?
oooh! that made my bowels move…in a good way. i had been constipated for days.
I think he stands next to me at church!
I haven’t laughed this hard in years! Thank you for a brighter day!
…I just wet my pants……
Outstanding! Reminds me a lot of Adam Sandler in The Wedding Singer….comedy genius… :)
I think he stands next to me at church!
This is the greatest thing to happen to the Christmas season since the birth of Jesus.
Oooohhh my ears hurt!!!!
Surely he did it for a laugh! Brighten my day anyway!
I think I might have to listen to it once more, there has to be one note where he is singing in key.
Dont give up the day job!
I have to first thank my friend Deb for having this link on her Facebook and the person who put Rob Vince’s link to youtube to watch the original guy who sang it. The reason I want to say Thank You is because I ended up clicking on this amazing 7yr old with the most Angelic voice I’ve ever heard for age. Enjoy! :-) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIQl6ygRqhw
Doing this as a lip syncing act (for the second time) at our church’s Christmas Coffee House (youth ministry fundraiser). This is my favorite Christmas song… not necessarily O Holy Night, but just this recording of it.
It is a beautiful sound in the ears of the Lord, for it gives him praise & the fellow singing is worshipping his God, which is what we were created to do! I enjoyed it!!=) When was the last time you worshiped with all your heart & soul!!!!!=)
This has made me cry with laughter – thank you :)
If this is what Musicademy calls “singing in harmony” I’ll beg to differ – or maybe I’ll just beg for some earplugs…
Yup! Even the serious angels have gotta enjoy this one.
definitely someone goofing around. even a full-up autotune would not fix this, lol. in some places it even sounds like adam sandler. this recording does have a serious message though, at that is: unless you are a good singer and have a great accompaniment, it’s best to leave “o holy night” for the experts and out of your song set, LOL!
Well, I think he sang just as good as me. But most of all, if it came from his heart, that makes it beautiful in Gods eyes! God Bless him! :-)
Out of kindness, shouldn’t his wife have a quiet word in his ears? It was, however, a truly inspired performance.
It was like chalk inside of my ears. My head rattled as I tried to listen to the end. My 7-yr old son came running in my office. He thought something had happened to me.
It seems as though it is part of a comedy routine because no one in his or her right mind would record a song of this caliber and believe it to be pleasing to the ear.
I do have sensitive hearing so many sounds can be troubling to me. However, this person may just be praising our Lord and Savior with all his might. It may be unpleasing to me, but to the Lord it gives Him glory and pleases His soul.
ahh that made me laugh sooo hard! It stirred up my cough (good to get it out of my system!) I’m glad it’s a joke – very clever man! I can’t wait to show some friends this! Thanks for sharing!
You know, I heard an animal make that noise once. I rolled him over and he was dead.
Seriously, that is so bad it’s brilliant! And for the record, it’s not me singing. No, honestly, it’s not! :P
But it doesn’t matter how badly you sing; just make a joyful “noise” to the Lord. In this case, a really bad noise.
yikes!!!!!! yyyiiiiiiiikkkeeeeeeees!!!
6 Trackbacks
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Rob Vince, Alt.Worship. Alt.Worship said: Christmas Carol Nightmare: A seasonal worship trainwreck – it gets beter the longer you liste… http://bit.ly/6UuxSW #god #jesus #christ [...]
[...] http://www.musicademy.com/2009/12/worship-gaffe-2-christmas-carol-nightmare/ [...]
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Alt.Worship, Marie Page. Marie Page said: This is our very favourite XFactor-style appalling audition meets Christmas http://bit.ly/i7sFES Some very funny comments too [...]
[...] is also THE BEST WORST singing of a carol. It just gets “better” the longer you listen. A real gem. Hap tip [...]
[...] since single link blogs are an abomination, I will add the following musical performance, passed on by Maggi Dawn. About ten seconds in you can hear a fluttering noise as the Holy Spirit pulls out of its descent [...]
[...] Detta hämtade jag från Andrew Browns Guardianblogg. Och det är sant som det sägs: det blir bättre [...]